Dear friends,
When Peter and I became Christians in the middle of the 20th century, the great atheist mathematician and philosopher of the time was Bertrand Russell. He produced a book of great effect entitled Why I Am Not a Christian. We both read it, as most of our contemporaries seemed to have as well, yet it didn’t talk either of us out of being a Christian. So this week, I will be asking Peter why he is still a Christian. The answer to that question is too long for one episode, so this will be Part 1 of 2.
I hope you enjoy this episode and share it with your friends.
Yours,
Phillip
Phillip Jensen: Peter, you wrote an article some time ago called Why I’m Still a Christian.1 In this episode, I wanted you to tell us what you said in this article. But before we start, I would like to ask this question: when and how did you become a Christian?
Peter Jensen: Let me illustrate by talking about what I call ‘the swearing conundrum.’ I can still remember bursting into swearing in my first year at secondary school, when I was 13. Our parents, as you will remember, never used bad language—at least not in front of us. But to impress my peers, I had to speak their language, which was pretty foul. So I did, and it felt quite good. Now, swearing is not the greatest sin in the book, and virtually all of us have had an experience of it. It’s hardly worth remarking on, except that when I tried to stop, I found I couldn’t. I was powerless. It was not the fact of a relatively trivial sin which impressed itself on me; it was the power of the sin. It was as if I’d given up my freedom to speak in order to join a club to impress people. When, later on, I read the words of Jesus in John 8:34, “Everyone who practices sin is a slave to sin,” I understood them at once.
Two years later, I was confronted with Mr. Billy Graham who told us the story of Noah: of God’s judgement on sin and the way of salvation. I already respected the authority of the Bible. I grew up in a Bible-believing context. But what I lacked was any relational encounter with the living God. So I turned to Christ in repentance for all my sins, and entrusted myself to him as Saviour and Lord. So that was the moment—April 20, 1959, at 3:00 or 4:00 in the afternoon—that I became a Christian: someone in a relationship with God. It occurred at the height of post-war churchgoing. There’s a book written by Callum G. Brown called The Death of Christian Britain.2 But there’s been a death of Christian Australia too. Since then, as we know, church attendance has slumped dramatically in most of the Western world, and cultural Christianity is virtually no more.
Phillip: The Sunday school you and I went to was for the children of the suburb, whereas the Sunday schools today are for the children of churchgoing families.
Peter: Yes, it’s an absolutely different world. Hence the biggest Sunday school in Sydney was the one at Kingsgrove. Do you remember how many kids attended?
Phillip: It was over 1,000 children, correct?
Peter: Yes. They built a big hall as a result. Parents used to drop the kids off at the Sunday school; that no longer happens. The turning point happened in the 1960s—the crucial decade for spiritual life, where nominal churchgoing and Sunday school and all those things simply fell away.
Phillip: So you became a Christian in 1959, just before that spiritual decay. The article you wrote was called Why I Am Still a Christian, and I presume the answer to that is because the Lord says, John 10:28, “No one will snatch them out of my hand.” So I was expecting the article to be about God’s sovereignty. But instead, you spoke of the human struggle of remaining a Christian, which is a struggle through doubt, reasoning, questions, and the like. Did you go through a season of doubt? Did you doubt occasionally, or was it a constant part of your life?
Peter: I did get through these periods of doubt, but I thank God for it. I want to talk about doubt because it’s one of those things which is hard for Christians to admit to, or to talk about. But yes, certainly, I went through periods of doubt that Christianity was true, and that I should be a Christian. These were difficult times. It was impossible early on in Christian life, for example, for me to miss Bertrand Russell’s volume, which was very popular back then, Why I Am Not a Christian.3
In the mid-20th century, Bertrand Russell was a British philosopher and mathematician who had a huge intellectual reputation, and was known for making public statements about all sorts of subjects. He was a person whose name you couldn’t miss, and therefore Why I Am Not a Christian was a volume you couldn’t miss either.
Phillip: You could say he was the Richard Dawkins of the 20th century.
Peter: So when I saw his book, at around age 16 or 17, I knew that I didn’t want to be a Christian just because I was brought up that way or had been tricked into it. So I nervously purchased a copy, willing to be persuaded out of my faith. But all that the book did for me was confirm my faith. I thought, “If this is the best that the best of the unbelievers can do, I’d rather be a Christian.” The arguments just didn’t add up. Interestingly, a more serious threat to my faith came when I was in theological seminary here at Moore College.
People get the idea sometimes that a seminary like ours is a rather sheltered workshop where you can’t possibly speak any differently from anyone else. Well, for a start, the library was completely uncensored. We were encouraged to read widely and to attend the lectures of great scholars of all persuasions when they came to visit. I can remember Bishop John A. T. Robinson, who had a big reputation as a liberal Christian, came to lecture at Moore College.
Phillip: He wrote a book, Honest to God,4 which was a great rejection of Christianity as we know it.
Peter: Yes, and the lecturers also regarded it as their duty to introduce us to modern biblical criticism as it was back then. In my second year at Moore College, I can remember being confronted with a view of John’s gospel which was alien to what I had believed. So doubts about the Bible haunted my mind and heart for months.
Phillip: It’s interesting that this is the same experience that I had, and still have, as I have read a lot of atheist literature. I wonder sometimes how these authors got their academic credentials, because the arguments are so weak. But in my second year at Moore College, I remember reading a book by an Old Testament professor from Cambridge about the authority of the scriptures, and being completely rattled because I didn’t know anything about the subjects that he was writing about. I hadn’t been told at church about the idea that the Hebrew Bible copied from the Gilgamesh epic and so on. Here was this man of great learning providing profound arguments and historical evidence to show that the Bible couldn’t be trusted in the sense in which I was trusting it. It’s funny that the books published outside in the wider world to persuade us out of faith seem to have very little effect upon us, but the books written and read inside our theological education were quite troubling.
Peter: Yes, that was my experience too. But I coped with my doubts by sharing them with some of my fellow students. No one panicked, including faculty—instead, we quietly worked through the issues. As we did so, I began to see things which I hadn’t seen before. In the end, after months of this, my trust in God’s word, far from being destroyed forever, was restored. Furthermore, I was given a method of living with doubt without capitulating to it, but learning from it. Doubt was an opportunity to learn and to grow without feeling that I had to fall over and crawl away. This help that I received did not come through people saying, “The Christian faith must be true, so stop thinking like that.” My teachers were even prepared to say the Christian faith may not be true. It could be based on something fraudulent, in which case we must abandon it rather than live a lie. There is the possibility of it being false. But they also showed me that there’s value in holding some things in suspension.
Someone once used an illustration of those houses in Brisbane which are built on big stilts to prevent damage from flooding. But if one of the stilts gets infested with white ants and you take it out, the whole house doesn’t fall down. You take it out, fix it, then put it back in again. I found that useful. So doubts can help you to understand Christianity better and to grow in maturity.
Phillip: It’s also an important part of training in Christian ministry. If you’re going to help other people to see the truth of God’s word, it is helpful to have worked through the issues that they may have doubts about, so that you know how to help them as you were helped. It’s also important to look at evidence. I’ve read about the issue brought up by the Gilgamesh epic, and I know exactly why it is that I’m unpersuaded that the Bible is secondary to that text because I’ve looked at the evidence for it. So it’s important, in training ministers of the gospel, that they are free to think, explore, doubt, and inquire like this.
Peter: Yes, it is. As I look back, there were 2 things that were very helpful for me. The first was the help I received from friends who didn’t panic, but kept talking to me. I owe a great debt to my friend Jim Ramsay, for example. There was also our great teacher, Donald Robinson, who was a man of huge intellect and was willing to see new things. He was, in a way, radical in his thinking. But he just quietly worked through issues and saw their truth. He was a model for dealing with reality rather than just our make-believes.
Phillip: When I came to Moore College, I came with such confidence through the Systematic Theology studies we used to have at Youth Fellowship from Louis Berkhof’s book.5 I thought I knew all the answers. That was a mistake, to put it mildly. Now more than ever, I recognise that I still do not know all the answers. But it was Donald Robinson in particular who kept showing me that I didn’t understand the Bible properly. He faced up to questions, and seemed very comfortable in seeing new information shift his thinking. He was a great model to me.
Peter: I mentioned reading Bertrand Russell. Who have you read?
Phillip: There’s a professor in Australia who’s now gone into politics, who said that Dawkins’ book The God Delusion6 persuaded him into atheism, and I think, “how?” It’s such a philosophically weak book, and the longer it’s been present in public debate, the more you see the weaknesses that Dawkins has in his viewpoints on life. Yet it sold millions. It’s those kinds of books which I find very unconvincing, because they do not understand Christianity at depth in their disparaging of it. Again, I thank Moore College for taking me through thinking at a much deeper level as to understand what it is that the Bible is teaching.
Peter: It was no accident that we had a course in philosophy at college. You’d expect that at seminaries, but by no means all seminaries, particularly evangelical ones. But that course was useful.
Phillip: I remember one student saying, “We’re at a Bible college. Why are you teaching us philosophy?” to which the lecturer was a little offended. But those philosophy lectures have stood me in good stead for many years, because you do need to understand where Western thinking has come from in order to understand where it has gone, and why people are disillusioned in the ways they are. They keep repeating the arguments of the ancient world without knowing that’s where they’ve come from, and that they have been answered.
But amidst learning not to panic, and the struggles with friends, why are you still persuaded to be a Christian?
Peter: I suppose there are many things that persuaded me. There’s the way in which the Christian gospel makes sense of our world, for example, and sustains our life. But I’d have to say that the central thing that sustains me is Jesus.
Take, for example, his words. When you’re looking into this, you don’t have to believe that the Bible is the inspired word of God. You just have to be prepared to at least take it seriously, which you ought. It is one of the greatest books of the whole of the civilised world, so reading it is a very good thing to do as an unbeliever. But when you do and you come across Jesus, you see that the gospels are history and not myth. If you’re prepared to have an open mind about the possibility of there being one true God who is able to rule all things, miracles are not impossible. But central to all this is Jesus, a man of extraordinary insight expressed in extraordinary words. His words and phrases have entered into our daily language; these are words which confront us, penetrate us, transform us, and inspire us. There is, for example, Matthew 7:1, “Judge not, that you be not judged.”
Phillip: Acts 20:35, “It is more blessed to give than to receive.”
Peter: Mark 10:25, “It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich person to enter the kingdom of God.”
Phillip: Matthew 6:24
No one can serve two masters, for either he will hate the one and love the other, or he will be devoted to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve God and money.
Peter: Matthew 4:19, “I will make you fishers of men.”
Phillip: Matthew 6:25–26
Therefore I tell you, do not be anxious about your life, what you will eat or what you will drink, nor about your body, what you will put on. Is not life more than food, and the body more than clothing? Look at the birds of the air: they neither sow nor reap nor gather into barns, and yet your heavenly Father feeds them. Are you not of more value than they?
Matthew 6:6–7
But when you pray, go into your room and shut the door and pray to your Father who is in secret. And your Father who sees in secret will reward you.
And when you pray, do not heap up empty phrases as the Gentiles do, for they think that they will be heard for their many words.
Peter: The list is practically inexhaustible. It’s interesting that people are using these phrases without realising their source, but Jesus was a master of words.
Phillip: The Good Samaritan, The Prodigal Son. These phrases are part of our everyday language.
Peter: Or take the Lord’s Prayer. I can remember our older brother, our beloved Ralph, pointing out to me that one of the wonders of the Lord’s Prayer is its brevity. People tend to pray at great length, but the Lord’s Prayer is very brief—yet it encompasses everything, and to this day it’s used on public occasions millions of times a day all around the world.
You’ve mentioned the parables. If you study them, they’re astonishing. The parable of The Prodigal Son is not about the son who runs away, comes back and is received with joy by his father. It’s about the older brother who never went away, who says to the father, “This son of yours,” (not “this brother of mine”) “has come back and you have killed the fatted calf.” It’s absolutely brilliant. It’s like a joke, but the trouble is that there’s no punchline. The older brother has his say, the father has his say, but there’s no conclusion, and that’s the genius of it. You ask yourself, “Who am I in the story? The self-righteous older brother, full of pride, unable to relate to his father and his brother? Or am I like the younger brother?”
Phillip: Doing children’s work for many years, I would come to the lesson on the Prodigal Son or the Good Samaritan, and I’d think, “This is going to be an easy lesson.” But they are terribly difficult lessons to teach because the kids would say, “Ah, I know that one.” You hear it once, you remember it. It’s very hard to hear the Good Samaritan or the Prodigal Son without being not only confronted by it, but remembering a story which was told 2,000 years ago in a couple of hundred words.
Peter: I’ve preached on the Prodigal Son any number of times in no less than half an hour. Yet Jesus took 2 minutes. We’re still talking about his words 2,000 years after he said them. And it’s not just the Christians who talk about it. I’ve got a couple of books at home about the great speeches of history. They mention those of Abraham Lincoln, Martin Luther King and the like. But each one of them also contains the Sermon on the Mount. These books are put together by people who aren’t believers, but they know, whether you like it or not, that the Sermon on the Mount is one of the greatest speeches in history.
But Jesus is not just a person of words. Shakespeare was a person of words. Oscar Wilde was a person of words. But the difference here is that the words of Jesus surround and explain his central claim: that the kingdom of God is at hand. Indeed, when it’s revealed in the gospels, he is the king of this Kingdom of God. He wasn’t just writing history; he was moving history.
Shakespeare’s words fill you with wonder and insight. Wilde’s words make you admire and smile at Oscar Wilde. The words of Jesus Christ invite you into a relationship with him, invite you to trust him, invite you to be his servant even today. They reach out to you. These words have changed the world. Ultimately, as Napoleon Bonaparte pointed out, they created the largest empire in the world: the empire of those who will give up all to follow him. That’s the power of the words of Jesus.
Phillip: The words come with the man as well. One of the problems in writing fiction is in trying to write a believably good person. Often, they turn out like Pollyanna: unbelievably good. Or with a real problem in their culture. But here is this man who lives what he preaches and preaches what he lives, and he is believable as a good man, which makes the gospel writers either geniuses, or people who have come across the man.
Jesus is so important to you, but how do you picture him in your mind?
Peter: I can remember Billy Graham once saying, “He must have been a man of greater strength and handsomeness than Samson. He’s God come among us.” It seems to me just as likely that he was short, maybe slightly fat. We don’t know. In fact, there’s nothing said in the New Testament about his height, the way he walked, his face, his hands, or any other feature.
Phillip: I saw a video the other day of a singer who was described as “looking like Jesus”. He had a well-trimmed beard. He had long hair which was casual, but all in place. Absolutely perfect teeth. A symmetrical face. The crowd that he was singing to were like that, too. It took me some time to work out that it was all an AI fake. But there’s nothing in the Bible that would give you any indication that Jesus was so startlingly handsome, attractive, or physically powerful. So you don’t picture him like that.
Peter: I don’t think we’re supposed to picture him. But in a dozen incidental ways, the Gospel makes clear that he was truly human, not angelic. He had his disciples, but within this group of disciples he had some special friends. He had to sleep. For example, he was sleeping in the boat when they woke him up to calm the storm. He had to eat like the rest of us. In other words, for all we know, he might’ve been thin and balding, with short sight and bad teeth. I don’t know. I’m not suggesting he was. But I think the absence of a description is deliberate. It means that we must focus on his words and his deeds. He clothes himself in those words and deeds, and that’s how we appreciate him. The events of healing, stilling storms, and feeding the 5,000 are integral to the account of him. Sorry if you don’t believe in miracles. You must go back at one stage and ask yourself, “Do I believe in a God who can do these things?” I do, and it’s not stupid or irrational to do so. They fit in with an existing pattern of revealing God to be at work here, as in Exodus or Elijah.
Phillip: Yes, but the people who were watching it didn’t believe in it either.
Peter: Some did and some didn’t.
Phillip: No, they believed that he did it, but they didn’t believe in miracles.
Peter: Because miracles are not proofs in that sense.
Phillip: In fact, the word ‘miracle’ is not the word in the Bible.
Peter: No, it describes them as ‘signs and wonders’.
Phillip: And in response, most of the time, the gospels say, “They were astonished.” If you believe in miracles philosophically, you’d be looking for miracles. They weren’t looking for miracles, but they were astounded at what they saw in this man, because he did that which you don’t expect a man to do.
Peter: No—and what he did in any case was for the benefit of others. He healed the sick; he fed the hungry; he stilled the storm.
Phillip: But he also did these things because of Old Testament prophecies.
Peter: Yes. And the pattern of the Old Testament is that when there was a great revelation of God, as in Exodus and Elijah, then there were signs and wonders surrounding them. A way of attracting attention to what God is doing, and a way of explaining it. But the signs and wonders are in a sense secondary to the main event.
Phillip: The parable of the rich man and the poor man comes to mind. The rich man goes to Hades and the poor man goes to Abraham’s bosom. The man in Hades is suffering, and he says to Abraham, “Send back the poor man to warn my brothers of what’s coming.” And Abraham’s words in the parable are, Luke 16:31, “If they do not hear Moses and the Prophets, neither will they be convinced if someone should rise from the dead.”
So Jesus recognises that believing in him just because of miracles has missed the point. We’re told in Mark 6 that he walks on the water, he stills the storm, and he climbs into the boat, and the disciples do not believe in it because they didn’t understand the feeding of the thousand.
Peter: Why am I still a Christian? Because of Jesus. Although I cannot picture him, I know him. I know his words, and I know what he did. Events like the miracles we’ve just spoken of are integral to every account of him. He came to a people carefully prepared—to a world made ready. All the great legal and prophetic systems of the Old Testament explain and prefigure him. But it’s what so often accompanied the signs and wonders that interests me. They give us the man.
I love that story where he’s confronted by a leper. The leper should not have drawn near to him, according to the rules of the day. He himself should’ve drawn back in a sort of sanctified horror that a leper would come close to him. But the leper pleads for healing, and then Jesus does something remarkable. He reaches out his hand and touches the leper. You didn’t touch lepers. You didn’t even get anywhere near lepers. But there’s something in the heart of Jesus that made him touch the leper, and he healed him.
And when Jesus was questioned by the rich, young ruler, the man didn’t receive what Jesus said very well. But we’re told that Jesus, looking at him, loved him. When Jesus was confronted with the tomb of his friend Lazarus, he wept. He grieved. He saved the life of a woman who committed adultery by confronting the accusers with their own sin. John 8:7, “Let him who is without sin among you be the first to throw a stone at her.”
On the other hand, he stood with a majestic silence in front of the monstrous King Herod, and that silence is the most terrible judgement of all upon such royalty. God refused to speak to Herod. When his disciples scrupled about the menial task of foot washing, he did it himself. When a woman of dubious morals washed his feet, he understood that her devotion sprung from forgiveness, and he rebuked the hard-hearted host.
Phillip: It’s interesting that so many of these accounts of Jesus involve relationships with others. You see that in the number of episodes about food.
Peter: Yes, I love his culinary habits. What do you have in mind?
Phillip: I’m thinking of the fellowship meals he had, where the Pharisees complained that he ate with sinners. The Pharisees said that if Jesus were a holy man, he would have known who was at the table and so he wouldn’t have eaten with them. Whereas Jesus is the holy man who cleansed the leper, rather than being defiled by the leper.
Peter: And when he was immortalised, he was immortalised not in a stone, not in a statue, not in a picture, but in 2,000 years of a special memorial meal. A meal which grounds us in the last events of Jesus’ life, explains their connection with forgiveness through his death, and bears testimony to his continuing presence. If nothing else would draw me to Jesus as the King in God’s kingdom, it is his death. “Father,” he says of the very ones who have cruelly and unjustly put him so painfully and shamefully to death, “Forgive them. They know not what they do.” Only Jesus could turn the abomination of the cross into the greatest of all human symbols. The cross, the very touchstone of reconciliation between God and humanity.
No wonder the essayist Charles Lamb once said words to this effect: “If Shakespeare were to enter the room, we would all rise to meet him. If Jesus Christ entered, we would all kneel at his feet.” As he first entered my head, he has now captured my heart: the one who touched the leper. He is my Lord and my God.
Phillip: What an extraordinary man he is; the empire beyond all empires, without an army. The one who is remembered not by a statue, but by a meal that we share together. The one who transforms the human hearts that he has cleansed.
Peter Jensen. (2020). Why I Am a Christian. Churchman, Volume 134 (1).
Callum G. Brown, The Death of Christian Britain, 2009 (Routledge).
Bertrand Russell, Why I Am Not a Christian, 1967 (Touchstone Books).
John A. T. Robinson, Honest to God, 1963 (Westminster John Knox Press).
Louis Berkhof, Systematic Theology, 1996 (William B Eerdmans Publishing Company).
Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion, 2025 (PEN Transworld).
Scripture quotations are from The ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), copyright © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
Links & Recommendations
For more on this topic, check out this talk by Phillip given at St. Andrew’s Cathedral on The Model Conversion.
Freely available, supported by generosity.
If you enjoy Two Ways News, why not lend us a hand? Consider joining our Supporters Club—friends who make it possible for us to keep producing this article/podcast.
To join the Supporters Club, follow the link below to the ‘subscribe’ page. You’ll see that there’s:
a number of ‘paid options’. To join the Supporters Club take out one of the paid ‘subscription plans’ and know we are deeply grateful for your support!
also the free option (on the far right hand side)











